Motor Vehicles Act — Enhancement of compensation — Assessment of income, disability and future prospects — Multiplier method — Applied in injury case (Paras 13–19) In an appeal seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the MACT, where the claimant (aged 35 years, electrician) suffered amputation of left leg below knee resulting in 70% permanent disability, the High Court held that notional income must be realistically assessed having regard to socio-economic conditions, and addition towards future prospects is permissible even in injury cases. Applying multiplier ‘16’, and treating functional disability affecting earning capacity, the Court recalculated loss of future earnings and held that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal was inadequate and required enhancement. (Paras 13–19)

advocatemmmohan

AP HIGH COURT HELD THAT

Motor Vehicles Act — Scope of appeal — Enhancement only — Negligence and liability not in dispute (Para 13)

Where the appeal is filed only by the claimant seeking enhancement of compensation and no appeal is preferred by the insurer, the findings of the Tribunal regarding occurrence of accident, rash and negligent driving, and liability of respondents remain undisturbed, and the scope of appeal is confined only to quantum of compensation. (Para 13)

---

Insurance — Defence of no valid driving licence — Burden of proof — Mere plea insufficient (Paras 7, 21)

Where the Insurance Company contended that the driver of the offending vehicle had no valid and effective driving licence, but failed to adduce evidence to substantiate such defence, the Court held that mere pleading is insufficient to avoid liability, and the insurer remains liable under the policy. (Paras 7, 21)

---

Assessment of compensation — Functional disability — Future prospects — Enhancement of compensation (Paras 16–21)

In a case where the claimant (aged 35 years, electrician) suffered amputation of left leg below knee resulting in 70% disability, the Court held that income must be reasonably assessed, future prospects added, and functional disability considered for loss of earning capacity, applying multiplier ‘16’. Adopting a liberal approach to “just compensation”, the award was enhanced from ₹5,81,053/- to ₹11,19,253/- with interest. (Paras 16–21)