EMPLOYEES’ STATE INSURANCE ACT, 1948 – Coverage – Determination – Number of employees Paras 2, 4, 10, 11, 16 Coverage under ESI Act depends on number of employees engaged – Petitioner contended only five workers engaged as per contract – Respondents relied on Form-I showing 27 employees – Held, determination of coverage requires proper verification of factual matrix.

advocatemmmohan

EMPLOYEES’ STATE INSURANCE ACT, 1948 – Coverage – Determination – Number of employees

Paras 2, 4, 10, 11, 16

Coverage under ESI Act depends on number of employees engaged – Petitioner contended only five workers engaged as per contract – Respondents relied on Form-I showing 27 employees – Held, determination of coverage requires proper verification of factual matrix.

---

ESI ACT – Section 45A – Determination of contribution – Validity

Paras 11, 13, 17

Order passed under Section 45A determining contribution payable – Petitioner challenged as arbitrary and without proper verification – Held, such determination must be based on proper enquiry and supporting material.

---

NATURAL JUSTICE – Opportunity of hearing – Compliance

Paras 12, 17

Authorities issued C-18 notice and provided opportunity of hearing – However, subsequent material (certificate showing no work during relevant period) not properly considered – Held, effective opportunity requires consideration of relevant evidence.

---

ESI PROCEEDINGS – Adhoc assessment – Requirement of proper verification

Paras 4, 17

Adhoc coverage and assessment without verification of records – Petitioner contended improper exercise of power – Held, authorities must verify records before invoking statutory provisions.

---

WRIT JURISDICTION – Interference – Remand for fresh consideration

Paras 17, 18

Where ambiguity exists regarding liability and relevant documents not considered – High Court set aside impugned orders – Matter remanded for fresh adjudication after giving opportunity – Held, appropriate course is remand.

---

PROCEDURE – Fresh notice and enquiry

Para 18

Authority directed to issue fresh C-18 notice – Petitioner to appear with records – Authority to pass reasoned order after hearing – Held, ensures compliance with Section 45A and principles of natural justice.